2023
1. Sweet Praxis Bake Lab: S'mores Cookie Dough Cup
2. Doug's Fish Fry: Fried Clams
3. Henry's Hen House: Fried Chicken
4. State Fair Deli: The Gotti Meatball
5. It's a Utica Thing: The Thing Sandwich
2022
1. Peachey's Baking Co: Sugar Glazed Donut
2. The Shamrock: Steamed Clams
3. Daniella's Steakhouse: Sausage Sandwich
4. State Fair Deli: Fried Provolone Sandwich w/ Pesto, Mozzarella, Tomatoes
5. Cinder BBQ: Brisket Sandwich
2021
1. Peachey's Baking Co: Blueberries and Cream Donut
2. Bosco's: Potatoes O'Rielly
3. Villa Pizze Fritte: Fried Dough
4. Sweet Praxis Bake Lab: Chocolate Chip Cookies
5. Toss 'n Fire: Margherita Pizza
2020
No Fair :(
2019
1. Sweet Praxis Bake Lab: Chocolate Chip Cookies
2. Josephine's: Glazed Donut
3. Villa Pizze Fritte: Fried Dough
4. Haddock's Paddock: Fried Fish Sandwich
5. Gianelli Sausage: Sausage Sandwich
2018
1. Shake It Up: Hot Beef Sundae
2. Villa Pizze Fritte: Fried Dough
3. Hammi's BBQ: Pulled Pork Nachos
4. Alivero's: Sausage, Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich
5. Baker's Chicken Coop: BBQ Chicken Sandwich
2017
1. Baker's Chicken Coop: BBQ Chicken Dinner
2. Gianelli Sausage: Sausage Sandwich
3. Seafood Tavern: Steamed Clams
4. Villa Pizze Fritte: Fried Dough
5. Fried Specialties: Fried Cheese Curds
2016
1. Shake It Up: Hot Beef Sundae
2. Fried Specialties: Fried Cheese Curds
3. Alivero's: Chicken Alivero Sandwich w/ Roasted Red Peppers, Mozzarella
4. Daniella's Steakhouse: Fried Green Tomato Sandwich
5. Anthony's 19th Hole: Curly Fries
2015
1. Hammi's BBQ: Bacon Bomb
2. Villa Pizze Fritte: Fried Dough
3. Haddock's Paddock: Fried Fish Sandwich
4. The Shamrock Tavern: London Broil Steak Sandwich
5. Seafood Tavern: Steamed Clams